October 17th, 2004
download
download
Hour 1:
Hour 2:
Anatol Lieven on his controversial critique of America's role in the world, as per his new book–the just published "America Right or Wrong: An Anatomy of American Nationalism." Lieven contends that U.S. foreign policy since 9/11 has been shaped by the special character of our national identity, which embraces two contradictory features. One, "The American Creed," is a civic nationalism which espouses liberty, democracy, and the rule of law. It is our greatest legacy to the world. But our almost religious belief in the "Creed" creates a tendency toward a dangerously "messianic" element in American nationalism, the desire to extend American values and American democracy to the whole world, irrespective of the needs and desires of others. The other feature, Jacksonian nationalism, has its roots in the aggrieved, embittered, and defensive White America, centered in the American South. Where the "Creed" is optimistic and triumphalist, Jacksonian nationalism is fed by a profound pessimism and a sense of personal, social, religious, and sectional defeat. Lieven examines how these two antithetical impulses have played out in recent US policy, especially in the Middle East and in the nature of U.S. support for Israel. He suggests that in this region, the uneasy combination of policies based on two contradictory traditions have gravely undermined U.S. credibility and complicated the war against terrorism. Lieven is a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for international Peace. He writes on a range of security and international affairs issues. He previously was editor of Strategic Comments, published by the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) in London. There he also specialized in the former Soviet Union and in aspects of contemporary warfare.
Dr. Graham Allison on U.S. vulnerability to a terrorist nuclear attack. While he begins by asserting such an attack is preventable, what Dr. Allison, the author of the new book "Nuclear Terrorism: the Ultimate Preventable Catastrophe," has to say beyond that is anything but reassuring. Allison describes the broad spectrum of groups who could intend a nuclear strike against the U.S. They range from an al-Qaeda with its own Manhattan Project to small and determined doomsday cults. Their tools can include a broad spectrum of weapons, either stolen or homemade from raw materials increasingly available worldwide. Once terrorists acquire a nuclear bomb, Allison argues, its delivery to an American target may be almost impossible to stop under current security measures. The Bush administration, correct in waging war against nuclear terrorism, has not, he says, yet developed a comprehensive counter strategy. Arguing that the only way to eliminate nuclear terrorism's threat is to lock down the weapons at the source, Allison recommends nothing less than a new international order based on no insecure nuclear material, no new facilities for processing uranium or enriching plutonium and no new nuclear states. Those policies, Allison believes, do not stretch beyond the achievable, if pursued by a combination of quid pro quos and intimidation in an international context of negotiation and a U.S. foreign policy he describes as "humble." A humble policy in turn will facilitate building a world alliance against nuclear terrorism and acquiring the intelligence necessary for success against prospective nuclear terrorists. It will also require time, money and effort. Like the Cold War, the war on nuclear terrorism will probably be a long struggle in the twilight. But no student of the fact, Allison asserts, doubts that another major terrorist attack is in the offing. "We do not have the luxury," he declares, "of hoping the beast will simply go away." Allison is the founding dean of Harvard's John F. Kennedy School of Government and is the director of the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs and the Douglas Dillon Professor of Government. He served as assistant secretary of defense for policy and plans and is also the author of Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Michael Klare, the author of the new book "Blood and Oil: the Dangers and Consequences of America's Growing Petroleum Dependency" on the world's rapidly growing economy which is dependent on oil as the world's supply is running out. As this happens, the U.S. and other great powers are engaged in an escalating game of brinkmanship to secure oil's continued free flow. Such is the premise of Klare's powerful and brilliant new book (following Resource Wars). The U.S.–with less than 5% of the world's total population–consumes about 25% of the world's total supply of oil, he argues. With no meaningful conservation being attempted, Klare sees the nation's energy behavior dominated by four key trends: "an increasing need for imported oil; a pronounced shift toward unstable and unfriendly suppliers in dangerous parts of the world; a greater risk of anti-American or civil violence; and increased competition for what will likely be a diminishing supply pool." In clear, lucid prose, Klare lays out a disheartening and damning indictment of U.S. foreign policy. From the waning days of WWII, when Franklin Roosevelt gave legitimacy to the autocratic Saudi royalty, to the current conflict in Iraq, Klare painstakingly describes a nation controlled by its unquenchable thirst for oil. Rather than setting out a strategy for energy independence, he finds a roadmap for further U.S. dependence on imported oil, more exposure for the U.S. military overseas and, as a result, less safety for Americans at home and abroad. While Klare offers some positive suggestions for solving the problem, in tone and detail this work sounds a dire warning about the future of the world. Michael Klare is the director of the Five College Program in Peace and World Security Studies at Hampshire College in Amherst. Defense analyst for The Nation and National Public Radio, he is the author of Resource Wars, Rogue States and Nuclear Outlaws, and Low Intensity Warfare.
Background Briefing, Part two:
John Judis, the author of the newly published "The Folly of Empire: What George W. Bush Could Learn from Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson" on how the neocon urge to dominate the world is ultimately wasteful and self-destructive. Surveying American foreign policy since the 1890s, New Republic senior editor Judis argues that when conservatives compare George W. Bush's post-9/11 speech to Congress with Roosevelt's "The Strenuous Life" (a speech that endorsed U.S. expansionism), they leave out Roosevelt's later doubts about expansionism and his support for international law and organization. While adopting Woodrow Wilson's goal of global democracy, conservatives, Judis says, have disregarded Wilson's recognition, through the example of Mexico, that the U.S. will stumble when trying to impose a government in the manner of McKinley and early Teddy Roosevelt: unilaterally. Where Judis identifies imperialist activity over the decades, he finds it grounded in America's sense of mission. But he also finds American torture in Iraq echoing American conduct toward Native Americans and in the Philippines and Vietnam: treatment meted out to "savages," not equals. He praises Bill Clinton for using NATO as not merely a military alliance but an "association of interest." Judis makes a strong case that Bush's repudiation of Clinton's support for numerous treaties and pacts has been shortsighted. He is a senior editor for The New Republic and has been a contributor to the magazine since 1982. His articles have also appeared in The American Prospect, The New York Times Magazine, The Washington Post, Foreign Affairs and many others. His books include The Paradox of American Democracy: Elites, Special Interests, and the Betrayal of Public Trust; William F. Buckley: Patron Saint of the Conservatives, and Grand Illusion: Critics and Champions of the American Century.
Gene Lyons is the co-author of the definitive "The Hunting of the President," which documented the orchestrated Republican effort to destroy the presidency of Bill Clinton. Lyons described in detail a Republican machine, funded by billionaires, which will corrupt any institution, governmental, media or religious, in the pursuit of power–and that machine is operating now as we head into perhaps the most important election in our lifetimes. Lyons' book was made into an acclaimed documentary, just released on DVD. The Hunting DVD unfolds like a paranoid thriller–made all the more astonishing by scrupulous documentation and an impressive breadth of interviews with journalists, lawyers, political analysts, judges, newspaper editors, and many of the people caught up in the Whitewater scandal–which, after an expense of nearly a hundred million dollars and several years of investigation, failed to find any criminal act. The relentless efforts of Clinton's enemies grow into an appalling abuse of power, ultimately resulting in his impeachment (but not his removal from office). This documentary, like those of Michael Moore, uses brief clips from Hollywood movies and television to give a boost to the narrative. The Hunting of the President presents such an impressive barrage of facts and perspectives that the argument it presents is overwhelming. Lyons is a nationally syndicated columnist and recipient of the National Magazine Award. He has written extensively for Newsweek, Harper's, The Nation and many other magazines. His books include The Higher Illiteracy, Widow's Web and Fools for Scandal.
George Butler on Senator John Kerry and on the controversy surrounding the Rovian "Swift Boat" campaign to attack Kerry's stellar Vietnam record. Butler is the director of the about-to-be-released documentary "Going Upriver," which explores the roots of Presidential Candidate John Kerry. Butler has known Senator Kerry since 1964 and in 1969 began photographing him, in an effort to document his life and career. Using his unique collection of images, the film weaves together Butler's photography with archival material, interviews with Kerry's closest associates as well as contemporary footage of him at home and abroad. As with Butler's films Pumping Iron and The Endurance: Shackleton's Legendary Antarctic Expedition and the IMAX feature "Shackleton's Legendary Antarctic Expedition, the filmmaker prove himself worthy of the acclaim he has received for being a master at portraying American men affected by and effecting history. Going Upriver: The Long War of John Kerry begins by juxtaposing beautiful images of Vietnam with horrific images of the Vietnam War. But though its depiction of the war is vivid–and the accounts of 2004 presidential candidate John Kerry's heroism, told by the men who served with him, are plain and free of hyperbole–it's his actions after he came back to the U.S. that stand out in this documentary. Kerry's involvement with Vietnam Veterans Against the War, for whom he became an inadvertent but eloquent spokesperson, required as much courage as facing the Viet Cong. Going Upriver gives a clear sense of the emotional and social pressures of the anti-war protests, where speaking one's mind became as powerful as firing a gun.
